Archive for the ‘Just stuff’ Category

Why I’ve parted company with Facebook

Friday, January 20th, 2012

Dislike stampLast weekend I had a bad experience that made me re-evaluate a lot of things I took for granted. I do recognise that my posts often tend to be contentious and sometimes downright controversial.  Last week I questioned a statement made by Pope Benedict about gay people which resulted in over 100 comments – strongly disagreeing with one another but good-natured and reasoned debate for the most part. For those who wonder why I often raise gay issues, it is simply because I believe gay people are treated appallingly by society and especially by Christians who should know better. My son Chris is gay and I’ve come to learn a huge amount as I’ve addressed the issue objectively. For me, it’s a justice issue. My equal opportunities statement says simply,

Every person is significant, important and of value and deserves to be treated with dignity, honour and justice

My review of  The Iron Lady ruffled some feathers as I was anything but sympathetic to the frail old lady portrayed in the film. It attracted positive and negative responses – but all friendly. My blog on Why I am a Welshman didn’t upset anyone but I was forced to issue a fatwah on my good friend Luke for his outrageous comments.

So last Saturday I read a claim in the Guardian that a drop in Tesco’s share price was ‘due to an answer to prayer’ for Stephen Green of Christian pressure group Christian Voice who protested outside shops last year after Tesco decided to sponsor the family area at London Gay Pride celebrations. I was angry about this as Stephen Green spouts absolute rubbish at the best of times, but to claim that God would answer such a vindictive prayer was insane and ludicrous.

As a result I posted that Stephen Green’s claims that God had judged Tesco were nonsense and that Green did more damage to Christianity than Hawking, Dawkins, Hitchens and militant Islam combined. What I didn’t expect were flames from my Christian friends quoting Bible verses: ‘Let him who is without sin cast the first stone…’ and various other personal attacks.

I’m pretty thick-skinned generally but this penetrated all my defences. I have worked hard for some years to build bridges between the Christian community in which I place myself and my many friends who don’t share my faith. Because I live and die by my equal opportunities statement above, I value all my friends equally. The friends who have touched my heart the most are those who formerly were part of a Christian group who have gone through divorces, or have come out as gay, or simply have lost their faith. They have been subjected to cruel, bitter, judgemental criticism by Christians and have been totally rejected. All of which is utterly contrary to the teachings of Jesus Christ whom the critics claim to serve. When I read the comments on my status I understood how they felt: despised and rejected of men.

I suspended my Facebook account and have just resurrected it to give this explanation to my friends and to give myself some time to reflect and regroup. And what is the ultimate irony? I received three concerned emails from friends who had noticed I’d disappeared and were checking on me. Two of those people were gay and all three would identify themselves as atheists.

Clarkson: Reality of Bigotry about Suicide

Sunday, December 4th, 2011
Gary Speed

Gary Speed

In a week when sports fans throughout the UK were saddened by the suicide of Gary Speed, I could not believe what I was hearing on the BBC1 One Show when Jeremy Clarkson made tasteless, insensitive and grossly inappropriate comments about people who chose to end their life on a railway line. For some reason, the media only latched on to the comments he made about strikers, who were demonstrating that day and our newspapers and TV have reported on the huge offence he gave to the trades union movement, generating some 25,000 complaints to the BBC.

In his regular column in the Sun on 3 December, Clarkson continued his whining complaints, describing those who choose to jump in front of trains as “Johnny Suicide”. He went on to make outrageously offensive comments about the bodies of those who had died on the railway Clearly, Clarkson has not experienced the torment of someone whose life is so excruciatingly painful that they see no alternative but to bring it to an end or the pain of the relatives who blame themselves because they did not read the signs of distress.

Last Monday, another man took his life. That man was Roger Crouch from Winchcombe, Gloucestershire, father of a 15-year-old boy. Dominic Crouch, who had six months previously, jumped from the roof of a six storey building because he had been unmercifully bullied at school. Fellow pupils in Dominic’s Gloucestershire school had taunted Dominic, calling him gay. Shortly after Dominic’s death, Roger Crouch was quoted as saying,

“If Dominic had not been the subject of rumours that he was gay it is highly unlikely he would have taken his own life.”

Roger & Dominic Crouch

Roger & Dominic Crouch

Roger became a tireless campaigner against teenage suicide and was awarded the Stonewall “Hero of the Year” award earlier this year. At the ceremony, he said,

“I see this as an award for Dom. By choosing us for this award you’ve also chosen to take a stand alongside all the young people whose lives have been ended by bullying.”

His wife Paola posted a moving piece in the Facebook page, Friends of Don Crouch against Bullying,

“I have the saddest news to give you. The love of my life and Giulia and Domi’s beloved Dad, died tonight. The changes you have started, for young people everywhere, the work you have done against bullying will remain as a towering monument to you. Our hearts break Roger, Domi, Giulia and I loved you so much.”

This is the reality of suicide that Clarkson has chosen to trivialise: three lives needlessly ended, two families devastated, many thousands of people who held Gary Speed in regard confused and distressed, the friends and families of Roger and Dominic shattered and distraught.

–oOo–

Useful support organisation related to suicide:

PAPYRUS UK Support organisation for teens thinking of suicide
Samaritans General support line
The Trevor Project USA Support organisation for gay, lesbian youth

Diary of a Day Occupying Cardiff

Saturday, November 12th, 2011

Paul at Snowdon summitAfter a 6am alarm, a drive from the shadow of Snowdon to Bangor Station, a four-and-a-half hour train journey, I was finally in Cardiff. My conscience had been troubling me that I was confining my left-wing commitment purely to blogging, so yesterday morning found me joining a hundred or so like-minded people (many 40 years younger than me!) at the foot of a statue to my hero, Aneurin Bevan at the Occupy Cardiff protest.

Just before we set off I was handed a leaflet, ‘What to do if arrested’. Suddenly the reality of what I was doing hit me. I had no plans to break the law but could easily be included with a group less cautious than I am! When we left, I had been hoping we would be greater in number, carrying more banners, but I had my walking boots and waterproofs against the rain that set in at 2pm precisely, and was prepared for a two-hour march. Two minutes after setting-off we had crossed the busy road to Cardiff Castle – and we had arrived! Swiftly jumping down from the pavement to the grass alongside the castle, the group set up tents and started its first General Assembly – a key component of the Occupy movement – which allows anyone to speak.

The General Assembly

The General Assembly

That was the point when the weaknesses of operating an egalitarian group began to show themselves. Hesitation over who was facilitating the Assembly, a loud-hailer which was not up to the task, people not shown how to use the loud-hailer, batteries that were quickly exhausted with no replacement; all leading to disappointment that we couldn’t hear what was said. It would have helped to have more banners, some musicians, and some rehearsed chants to make for better engagement of all present. I believe there is a lesson here – having leadership, co-ordination and reference to a model that works elsewhere does not detract from the aims of equality for all. My other disappointment was despite a Cymdeithas yr Iaith banner, I heard no Welsh spoken. However, I was glad to see a later Tweet that the protest was the first time the, “We are the 99 per-cent” slogan had been heard in Welsh.

The police stood round in ridiculously over-the-top numbers looking embarrassed. There were mounted police, ordinary officers, community support officers, police cars, vans and, I suspect, every demonstrator could have been allocated his or her personal officer. Sadly, those officers waded in shortly after I left for my long trek back to North Wales, to remove the fledgling protest and the tents and some arrests were made.

I was energised by the passion and commitment of the participants and will take my experiences back to the nascent Occupy Bangor group. Hopefully, there will be a clear backlash against this attack on peaceful protest and the first Welsh expression of the Occupy movement will re-emerge to declare “We are the 99 per-cent”.